Once
upon a time they were inseparable, but then Jay-Z did an awful thing and Ed Whatley knew it was the end for them.
All of us have had that moment in a relationship. You’ve loved each other for a
long time, gone through good and bad, had some great times on cold nights in or
hot summer holidays. Helped each other through the shaky times, sticking
together even when you’ve had fallings out, let all those bad habits go and
still loved the make-up sex. But there’s that one moment, when you know, you
just know – it’s over. The person you loved has gone.
This year Jay-Z released a single, Young Forever. Oh God. Like a tearful
girlfriend confessing she’s been cheating after a day you’d set aside to just,
you know, hang out, like we used to, this song sat at the end of Blueprint 3,
Jay’s most recent album. Blueprint 3 isn’t bad, but it does have the whiff of
someone trying to make stadium hip hop. Of trying to get into Bono World.
Coldplay World. The world where Eno produces your album in between grotesque
charity events sponsored by Apple and attended by Naomi Campbell. See, Kanye West
and Jay worked out a couple of albums ago that if they were going to fulfil
their multi-million dollar live contracts they needed to start rapping slower.
Because in the same way that Led Zeppelin clocked in the 70s that you needed to
be loud as hell, and U2 realised in the 80s that you needed space between the
sounds, and Coldplay realised in the Noughties that you needed simple melodies
to get across to 100,000 people a night, you can’t rap quick and complex in an
icy barn to people who haven’t been listening properly. It. Has. To. Be. Slow.
And it can’t be too specific. And it can’t upset your sponsors. OK, all records
are made within parameters, that’s the nature of creation. But those are some
chokers.
So OK, she’s been hanging out with some new people. So OK, her career’s more
important than you; fair enough, you don’t own her. And look, you’ve had so
many great times together, like all those parties you went to (Give It 2 Me),
like all those good times in the sack (Big Pimpin’), like the time she kept
your head up when you were all broke down (Blueprint). But this song, this Young
Forever, she’s in flagrante dressed as a nun with his sexual effluent all over
her face. And the pictures are all over the internet. There’s no going back.
This song, this bloody song. A cover – not a sample, not an interpolation, a
frigging cover. A cover of an extraordinarily awful 80s pop turd bemoaning
impending nuclear doom, a doom that could be no worse than this glum and keening
gauche-fest. Played on awful portentous synths with a totally perfunctory
"beat", the hook is sung by Brit cipher Mr Hudson, sounding like an
autotuned duck with no sense of irony. And Jay? The greatest lyricist of his
generation?
"Fear not when, fear not why, Fear not much while we’re alive, Life is for living not living up tight, See ya somewhere up in the sky"
Below piss poor. A nod to drug-dealing later in the song. Wow. As bland, anodyne
and pointless as the worst Snow Patrol atrocity. It’s over. I’m sorry. I loved
you. It’s over.
And who can I start seeing now? Drake? Drake?
All she talks about is house prices. Lil Wayne’s druggy stream of consciousness
blither? I might as well shack up with Crazy Katy in the squat. Eminem? She
just isn’t... she used to be pretty.
I think I’m just going to have to stay in rap celibacy for a bit. Let the
wounds heal.
I did put a question mark after that greatest lyricist thing, I don't know if there is such a thing, and if there is I reckon it's Steve Malkmus.
I think the lyrics to Big Pimpin' are perfect, redolent of many of my nights out. When I met my now girlfriend I did indeed let her play with the dick in the truck.
In all honesty, Jay jumped the shark many years ago.
Still, this is a rather fine article with many a sound point, until the patent idiocy of calling Jay-Z the greatest lyricist of our time. It's, of course, a very fashionable argument but also one that is unforgivably asinine and revisionist (and I actually have a background in hip hop so that's not my problem with this argument).
To wit, the immortal lyricism of the "golden era" Jay: I thug em, fuck em, love em, leave em cause i don't fuckin need em take em outta hood, keep em lookin good but i don't fuckin feed em...
In the cut where i keep em till i need a nut, till i need to beat the guts then it's, beep beep, i'm pickin em up let em play with the dick in the truck
Comments
The problem with REM is every now and then they do something just as lovely as they've ever done, and you try and tell yourself nothing's changed.
I did put a question mark after that greatest lyricist thing, I don't know if there is such a thing, and if there is I reckon it's Steve Malkmus.
I think the lyrics to Big Pimpin' are perfect, redolent of many of my nights out. When I met my now girlfriend I did indeed let her play with the dick in the truck.
Still, this is a rather fine article with many a sound point, until the patent idiocy of calling Jay-Z the greatest lyricist of our time. It's, of course, a very fashionable argument but also one that is unforgivably asinine and revisionist (and I actually have a background in hip hop so that's not my problem with this argument).
To wit, the immortal lyricism of the "golden era" Jay:
I thug em, fuck em, love em, leave em
cause i don't fuckin need em
take em outta hood, keep em lookin good
but i don't fuckin feed em...
In the cut where i keep em
till i need a nut, till i need to beat the guts
then it's, beep beep, i'm pickin em up
let em play with the dick in the truck
RSS feed for comments to this post.